Survivor Literacy

Breaking the Cycles that Tried to Break Us


33) Man Hating

This commercial inspired Mary Chapin Carpenter to write “He Thinks He’ll Keep Her,” in response to its sexism.

If I were to characterize gender dynamics in the 90s, I would begrudgingly admit that the comedy of Tim Allen was all too close to true.

In this clip, Allen exhibits contempt for both sexes while displaying a love of privilege.

Mom had been raised to be exceptionally competent in a world that acts like anyone without a penis is somehow defective. She had always done “men’s work,” even though she did not get paid the same as her male counterparts, and she was always under greater scrutiny with less support.

After Dad died, she really just turned on men as a whole. She lost patience for pretending that it was acceptable for men to behave without consideration or compassion toward the people in their lives.

Mom had lived through catering to her brothers, and having to prove herself. She endured all of the accusations that she must be a dyke, just because she performed manual labor.

Take a little stroll with me, back in time.

The song above does a terrific job of showing how little girls were spoken to about careers when I was growing up. These lyrics were considered progressive at the time.

People still expected the word “obey” to show up in wedding vows. It was considered a given that she would take his last name, and give up her career once she started having children.

Men made a pretty big deal about all of the concessions they were making.

As a matter of fact, our current president was on record in the 90s talking about gender.

The most bold among us made waves by taking on “strong independent woman” roles. They were free from the strict confines of gender. Comedy truly is an incredible platform for paradox.

Wanda Sykes was even playing a straight woman back then. Even in pushing the boundaries, there were still limits.

Mo’nique made people deal with a woman being as unapologetic about power as a man. It stood out.

Even George Carlin sided with the feminists.

Thinking back on it, I think the man that Mom truly hated was Grandpa, but she was not allowed a voice there. If he rattled the ice in his glass, and there wasn’t someone else around she outranked, she would still jump to go fill it, without question.

I also think that she was very angry at Dad for leaving her all alone to live in the mess he made. He was supposed to be her forever. He was her second chance. He was the glue that was meant to mend our broken family.

She was angry at a world that made it so she had to attend a sit in at her high school to get the right to wear pants. She lived in a world where you were either your father’s property, or if you were very lucky, you would become the property of someone you love, and who loves you in return.

By the time I was 13, Mom was in full man-hater mode. Grandpa was off limits, and so was my brother but everyone else was fair game.

Mom tormented my favorite aunt’s husband (who had once been roommates with Dad). She was constantly telling him how dumb he was and making jokes at his expense.

We got points if we repeated those jokes that she was so proud of. We got extra points for providing original material.

My cousin was also consistently on the receiving end of her vitriol.

I must admit that I got really into it in my early teen years. Admittedly I grew up in this system of oppression as well. I went to school where boys got away with everything, and girls were blamed all of the time. I knew my life didn’t really matter, because I was here for some man I didn’t even know.

I knew that the oppression of that system would keep me one way or another, and it was easy to just blame men, and hate them.



What do you think?